You can check out the inovelli switches. They have zigbee switches coming soon.
this post was submitted on 26 Aug 2023
17 points (100.0% liked)
homeassistant
12025 readers
90 users here now
Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Powered by a worldwide community of tinkerers and DIY enthusiasts. Perfect to run on a Raspberry Pi or a local server. Available for free at home-assistant.io
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Great product, I have five of the dimmer only model in my house already and will be getting more. Properly (c)UL listed as well! Great company as well, highly recommended!
I can second these. Have haf a very positive experience with some of their Blue 2-1 switches (and in a 3-way setup with Aux switch).
It looks like they used to have a light+fan combo for z-wave but discontinued it.
Looks like the blue series will be out of beta by the time I need them, but I'd need to convert all my boxes to 2-gang and buy both devices separately. They look nice, but hopefully I can find something a little cheaper and/or single gang
Yeah, I feel you there, but the opposite (fans already in their own gang) and I use zwave. Maybe I'll switch those to zigbee. Some day.... Some day...
How comfortable are you re-flashing devices and doing a bit of event/automation programming? I use an iFan04-L for the fan+light and then coded the button events from a Martin-Jerry dimmer to change the fan speed and toggle the light.
You'd need to flash the iFan04 but you can get the MJ stuff with Tasmota preinstalled (Amazon stuff was different firmware but their website gives you a choice)
I would be comfortable with that, but I definitely prefer devices that retain the wall controls like a normal wall switch. And will work even if the smart home goes down. I should have mentioned that in my post.
The ifan has a remote, so not quite a wall switch, but still doesn't require HA to make things happen.
I just installed one in a fan in our dining room as a test. Flashed with Tasmota.
That's totally fair. In my case I was also limited because the location originally had just lights (so only hot+neutral+ground) but if you want to control lights+fan separately you need at least 3 wires+ground (common neutral, shared ground, hot for fan, hot for light).
In your case, maybe something like the Treatlife DS03 might do the job? I've never used it myself but it does have separate wires for load and fan-load, there's a Tasmota template, and still did a fairly decent write-up
Yeah your solution would be the best if I didn't have fan wiring going to the wall. I wouldn't want to make the wall switch totally obsolete.
I looked at the Treatlife but apparently they changed the chipset and it's no longer flashable :/
Ah, those freaking WB3S chips area huge pain in the ass we they've been replacing the ESP Tuya on newer models
I did the Treatlife DS02S switch by flashing an ESP12F module with ESPHome following the guide here, then swapped the wireless module.
Works well as a normal independent switch with local control from Home Assistant.