It's definitely tracked, I've taken a look at some of my comments on Lemmy and it has an indicator if I edited them. I think kbin just doesn't have the UI for it yet, but hopefully it can be added.
this post was submitted on 10 Jul 2023
23 points (100.0% liked)
/kbin meta
2 readers
1 users here now
Magazine dedicated to discussions about the kbin itself. Provide feedback, ask questions, suggest improvements, and engage in conversations related to the platform organization, policies, features, and community dynamics. ---- * Roadmap 2023 * m/kbinDevlog * m/kbinDesign
founded 1 year ago
Good to know, thanks for verifying that for me!
I for example almost always append an "Edit:" note even though it initially is Reddiquette not Fediquette. Also you could use Mastodon for kbin content, it shows edit notes and edit histories
Afaik kbin doesn't have any indication of such. The etiquette is to put a note when you edit your comment.
Reddit doesn't always put the edit/asterisk mark when someone edits. Rather, it gives a small time period (maybe 5 minutes) to "shadow" edit your comment, without any notification being made. This is to allow quick corrections/typos and the like, without getting marked as an edited comment. then later edits are marked by the system (even if you don't mention the edit).
Reddit's system, combined with a system I see often (on twitter and reddit) where you can see previous versions of the comment, I think are ideal. That way you can see that it's edited, what the previous version was, etc. but also still grant that typos happen without permanently marking something as edited.
Since kbin uses activitypub, I'm actually not sure how the edit feature works here on the fediverse. I know it's possible to edit, but how does syncing with that work?
maybe 5 minutes
IIRC 3 minutes
Useful information. I didn't realize reddit's version can show you the previous versions of a comment. That's great if you wonder if someone changed a comment in some fundamental way.
I tend to ninja edit comments all the time, but just to make things clearer and improve my writing. With a system that could show anyone the changes I made, I feel like I've covered all bases in terms of 'editing ethics'. And maybe someone will offer me money to become an editor someday!
On reddit you can't see the previous version of the comment, only that it's been edited. I had a typo/slip in my previous comment haha. I meant youtube. youtube+twitter allow you to see previous versions. Reddit only puts a note if it's edited after a few minutes of being posted (but not immediate edits)
Ah, ok. Still, I agree that a system that shows previous version would be nice for kbin
None of the apps have an indication, but it would be nice to have. I can just go and make people look silly by changing things and nobody would be the wiser :p
None of the kbin apps at least, but Lemmy apps (or at least Jerboa) do.
I use Jerboa (for Lemmy) and there's a parenthesis right next to the timestamp that indicates when the post/comment was edited.
Ahh, that makes sense! I'm still holding out for Artemis to release for Kbin. Hopefully they'll have this added somehow, too!
Typing this from the (closed) Artemis beta. So far, there is no edit indicator. But given that it doesn't even currently have the capacity to edit, it's not surprising that there are currently other things higher up the priority list than showing when something was last edited.
Also: Kbin doesn't currently have an API for clients, so Artemis has to work with scraping at the moment. That means the last-edited info is probably inaccessible to Artemis atm even if it were the highest priority right now.