this post was submitted on 03 Oct 2023
1123 points (97.8% liked)
Memes
45727 readers
723 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Funny how some older media are so much better for longevity, like CDs.
And the expected lifespan is still only 50-100 years.
That's a speck of sand it the human history.
Tape disk drives and tapes are actually some of the longest lasting, when stored properly. Tape isn't great for active data needs, where you need to read/write the data regularly. Super slow for that. But it's killer for writing once and then dropping it in storage.
Anyway, same thing with tapes, the length of time they last is a fraction of history, on top of needing proprietary hardware to play them.
For example, there was that recently unearthed pilot of a sketch comedy show from Monty Python's Graham Chapman and Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy's Douglas Adams. It's not particularly great, but it was lost to time except for a copy that Chapman had recorded to tape when the show first aired.
Problem was, that tape was so old when it was discovered, it pre-dated VHS and Betamax and was in a format that literally no players existed for anymore. This lead to a long effort to rebuild a player from scratch, which they eventually succeeded, and now it lives on YouTube for weird comedy nerd historians.
Anyway, the point being is that the mediums are short-term storage, for all intents and purposes, and that pretty much goes for all types of media humans uses, going as far back as stone tablets and books. The ones that survived were lucky and most are lost to time due to destruction or environmental degradation. At least with stone tablets and paper all you needed was to understand the language it was written in. Now we're going to need electricity and knowledge of historical data storage practices and technologies.
So, we're always losing history, and people who go out of their way to preserve history and put it in modern formats to attempt to keep the data from disappearing forever are doing a service to future human history. I would say, in this way, pirates who remove DRM from media are taking part in an act of historical preservation.
Yeah, I think as long as we can count on some level of society, we have a shot at longer term preservation. Like, computers will continue to get faster, and mediums will continue to get upgraded and transferred and so forth, and we're kind of already at a point where nothing recorded today needs to be "lost" with some careful planning. There are obvious holes in this, but it's increasingly less likely to be a problem that the storage medium is the issue (again, caveating that we're not talking about rebuilding society after a catastrophe or something) and more a problem with what the dependency of reading the data to be saved is, whether it's transferred on storage formats that maintain data integrity, etc.
Like, we can do redundant backups and so forth, but what if the things we're backing up are server dependent? Or even simpler shit like Flash games. I really hope that more people writing software especially think about how to keep it usable for a long time.